Cicero is concerned that he might appear to be partial, however, and that the sentence he might impose on Catiline would be criticized for that reason. This may color his decision to have Catiline exiled rather than executed, for if the batch object to the sentence, a death sentence allows for no correction. Cicero gives the masses the chance to make themselves heard l
ater, for he tells Catiline that he (Cicero) would not be able to guide the criticism that the people would heap upon him if he exiled Catiline and the people did not want him exiled.
Cicero selects banishment, which is wrong for all the reasons given above. Catiline has forfeited his rights in a number of ways.
He has no right to be heard by an impartial jury because there is no such thing remaining. He has forfeited his right to have intercourse among us. He has forfeited his right to life because we deserve security measure from him.
Consider the alternatives that Cicero could select. Imprisonment would control Catiline, but it would leave him a citizen of the country he has harmed and would force that country to take divvy up of him, protect him, and guard him. He has already cost the country enough in terms of grief and trouble, and again it leaves Catiline in a position where he might return to big businessman and achieve his original end. Clemency would have the same perfume and create a more immediate danger, and clemency is ill-considered without evidence that Catiline has changed his views and repented. There is no such evidence offered here. none of these punishments suffice
Ordercustompaper.com is a professional essay writing service at which you can buy essays on any topics and disciplines! All custom essays are written by professional writers!
No comments:
Post a Comment